American Idol - Was the save worth it?

Well, Jessica got the save last week.  Will it pay off this week?  Here's what we though about this week's songs:

NOW SONGS:
Name-------Dave----Shan----Emily----Tyler----
Hollie------Y-------Y--------Y--------?------
Colton------N-------Y--------N--------Y------
Elise-------?-------?--------?--------N------
Phillip-----Y-------Y--------Y--------Y------
Jessica-----Y-------Y--------Y--------Y------
Skylar------?-------Y--------Y--------Y------
Joshua------?-------Y--------Y--------Y------

THEN SONGS
Name-------Dave----Shan----Emily----Tyler----
Hollie------N-------Y--------Y--------Y------
Colton------N-------N--------N--------N------
Elise-------Y-------?--------Y--------Y------
Phillip-----Y-------?--------Y--------Y------
Jessica-----N-------?--------Y--------N------
Skylar------?-------Y--------Y--------?------
Joshua------N-------Y--------Y--------Y------


NOW Songs:
Hollie - Wow! Wow! Man, I thought she did great!

Colton - Um. No. He sounds flat or off or something to me.

Elise - Hmm. I don't know about this. Tyler says the pitch is changing too much. I just feel kinda flat about it. Nothing really special.

Phillip - Wow, way to make an USHER song your own. This dude kills it. Awesome! Shan says not his best.

Jessica - Dawg, this girl really could sing "Yankee Doodle" and knock it out of the park. Seriously, ya gotta vote, and ya gotta vote for her.

Skylar - She's good, but I am getting tired of her voice. Could I listen to a whole album of Skylar?  I'm not so sure.  This is just "meh" for me.  Shan likes her and the song. :-)

Joshua - He has 'old school r&b' all over him, and I know I've said that before. Like Skylar, though, I'm not sure I could listen to a whole album of his singing.  He is more of a 'small doses' kind of singer for me.

THEN Songs:
Hollie - Ouch, rough start. Not as good as her first song.

Colton - Uh, no. Wow, way to ruin a great song. Please send him home. Thanks.

Elise - Nice start! Now, this is the perfect song for her and her voice.

Phillip - Oh, yeah! Awesome!  This boy can sing, groove and get funky! Shan says she sees in him what I see in Skylar - same thing over and over. Funny thing is, I could listen to him over and over.

Jessica - Um, what was that "wuhwuhwUHEARY" thing there?? No no no.  She is trying way too hard on this one. Ouch. She could see the bottom three based on this song. Wrong song.

Skylar - Wow, can you say "twang much?" At least she made it her own.

Joshua - Well, it ain't Taylor Hicks. He is not pulling off that "sexy eyes" thing at all. LOL. What was that!?  Not a fan here in me. The rest of the family liked it.