American Idol - Top Nine (Again)

Michael got saved last week. Let's see if he earned it. And, who will drop out? Of course, TWO people will go home after the voting. Here we go:


Name----Dave----Shan---
Crystal---Y-------Y----
Andrew----N-------N----
Tim-------N-------N----
Lee-------Y-------Y----
Aaron-----Y-------Y----
Siobhan---N-------N----
Michael---Y-------Y----
Katie-----Y-------Y----
Casey-----Y-------Y----

Wow, out of all the alumni, they asked Lambert to mentor?? Disgusting. How can he mentor when he hasn't even done anything yet?

Crystal - Man, she is doing great - nice rocking soulful song! Excellent!

Andrew - Wow, can you say Cruise Ship? This is not good at all.

Tim - Shall I stay? As Shan said, "No, I think you'll be going home."

Lee - I actually like this version a lot. He has a very cool voice - a little Springsteen in there.

Aaron - Why would you pick a song you felt was wrong? It's fun, but kinda karaoke. Okay, I like the slow down there! Nice! Wow, I'm very surprised. Well done.

Siobhan - I don't know why she insists on wearing her hair all swept up like that. Ugh. This sounds very Broadway to me or something. I'm not feeling it.

Michael - I've never heard this song before. Michael's version is superb. This is the stuff of moving videos and commercials. This is the kind of performance that would bring tears to the eyes.

Katie - I've been getting to like Katie more and more. I hope she does well. Well, she's wearing something from the Selena Gomez collection, I think. Very nice job! I like this a lot.

Casey - I like the sound of his voice. Sounds a little like Travis Tritt in there. He'll make it safely for sure.