The not-so-sweet 16 on Idol

Okay, folks, here is our take on the ladies and the gents! Have fun!


Name-----Dave---Shan---Emily---Tyler--
Katie------N-----Y-------Y-------N----
Siobhan----Y-----N-------N-------N----
Lacey------N-----N-------N-------N----
Katelyn----N-----N-------N-------N----
Didi-------N-----N-------Y-------N----
Paige------N-----N-------N-------N----
Crystal----Y-----Y-------Y-------Y----
Lilly------N-----N-------N-------N----


Katie - Not a fan of her version.

Siobhan - I actually like this haunting version of "House of the Rising Sun"

Lacey - I am not a big fan of the 'babydoll' sound, and that seems to be where she lives. no thanks.

Katelyn - She looks like someone, but I can't think who. Like Melanie Griffith or something maybe? I dunno. Shan said she'd make a good backup singer.

Didi - Emily said YES right away. I, on the other hand, offer up a big sigh of boredom and disgust. Wake up when she go-gos… I'm so sick with singing slow-slow.

Paige - zzzzzzzzzzz…..

Crystal - Now, this is what I'm talking about! Groovin, getting into it. Well done!

Lilly - Holy cow. I was hoping for a great thing, but um no… Tyler said he sees a hippy chick when he closes his eyes. Shan says she sees Cyndi Lauper.

*Disclaimer - Tyler did not start watching until Crystal, but he said to mark NO for all the previous singers. That is my boy!

---

Here are the guys:


Name-----Dave---Shan----Emily---Tyler---
Lee-------N------N-------N--------N-----
Alex------N------N-------N--------N-----
Tim-------N------N-------X--------Y-----
Andrew----N------N-------X--------N-----
Casey-----N------Y-------Y--------Y-----
Aaron-----N------N-------X--------N-----
Todrick---N------N-------N--------N-----
Michael---Y------Y-------N--------N-----


Lee - Meh. Nothing going here for me.

Alex - Can you say "I sing through my nose?"

Tim - Man, come on… Where is the talent!?

Andrew - Shan said NO before Ryan even started talking after the break. What up with the guy singing all these girl songs!? Even Fox 16 didn't like him, they cut his audio! ROTFL!

Casey - Emily likes his name. UGH. Nah, I'm not into it. Shan likes it.

Aaron - Wow, what an awful, horrid start. And it did not get much better as he went on. He should go home. Really. Thanks for playing.

Todrick - Someone get their finger out of his butt - he is screaming like a cat with it's tail caught in the door. AUGH. We actually thought he had already been voted off.

Michael - Man, this dude is old school R&B all the way! Smooth voice, powerful soul. Excellent!